If You Add All The Negative Integers With Positive Integers, Would You Get Zero?

The sum of all integers forms an infinite series, the answer to which depends on the order of the partial sums within it.

We know that there are infinite positive integers and infinite negative integers. For the finite amount of them, supposing that the amount of both the positives and negatives is the same, when added together, would result in zero. This makes both intuitional as well as mathematical sense.

However, is it the same for an infinite number of these integers? Let’s check out this brain teaser in more detail!


Recommended Video for you:

If you wish to buy/license this video, please write to us at admin@scienceabc.com.

What is a Series in mathematics?

The addition of all the infinite integers (both positive and negative) is neither an easy nor straightforward task, so we need to begin by understanding the mathematical process behind it. To understand this process, we must first become familiar with the ideas of series and sequences in mathematics.

Let’s go in a sequence (no pun intended) and start with sequences first. So, what is a sequence in real life? In our day-to-day activities, we often arrange things sequentially. In the kitchen, the spices and herbs we use most often are kept forward, while those we rarely use are kept in the back.

Life cycle of apple tree

The sequence in which a tree grows. (Photo Credit : Kazakova Maryia/Shutterstock)

When a teacher takes test papers back from her students, they arrange the papers in the order of the roll numbers or names. There are many such examples of sequences in our daily lives and the most important thing about them is a pattern. All the sequences follow a pattern, so accordingly, the members of a sequence find their place.

The same is true in math. A sequence is a collection of numbers that all follow a certain rule or order. For example, we can create a rule as , where the value of i changes to give us the ith element of the sequence. Following this rule, the sequence would have the form 1, 4, 9, 16, 25, …and so on.

Now, a series is just the summation of the elements of a sequence. For example, the series of the sequence mentioned above would be

.

This signifies the sum of all the elements in the sequence of  until 5.

Summation flat design long shadow glyph icon

A series is the summation of all the elements in a sequence. (Photo Credit : bsd studio/Shutterstock)

Integers and their addition also form sequences, and their series is used to find the answer to the titular question of this article.

What are Convergence and Divergence?

We learned what a series is in mathematics: the addition of numbers that follow a specific rule. Now, there can be sequences that go on forever, meaning that there are infinite elements in them. The series of sequences with infinite elements are known as infinite series.

3d,Rendering,Of,An,Infinity,Loop,Shape,Object,Isolated,In

An infinite sequence has infinite elements within it. (Photo Credit : Make more Aerials/Shutterstock)

If, in the sequence mentioned in the previous section, instead of stopping at 5, we had gone on until infinity, then the infinite series would have looked something like this .

There are finite series with a single finite answer, such as the one that stopped at 5 (its answer being 55), but what about infinite series? Do they have a finite answer?

The answer is both yes and no.

The answer to an infinite series (a summation of infinite numbers) is taken by first finding a finite sum, and then applying the limit of infinity to it. What does that mean? The entire summation can be divided into n number of smaller summations. Then we apply a limit to these partial summations (applying a limit helps us find the answer using predefined formulae, without actually adding the infinite sums) to get the answer to the entire series.

Instead of actually adding all the infinite elements, we simply find the formula for the partial sum and then use the limit that tends to infinity on it and gets the answer using the predefined formulae of limits.

There are some series whose summation gets very close to a certain number. We can think of it this way, the summation of the numbers (the answer of the series) gets closer and closer to a certain number as we add more and more elements to the series, thus getting closer and closer to infinity.

It seems as if the series is converging to a single number. The answer to the series of such infinite numbers is that particular number; this property is known as convergence.

Management,Skills,Leadership,As,A,Leader,Organizing,Diverse,Ropes,Into

Various colorful lines converging at a single point. (Photo Credit : Lightspring/Shutterstock)

Now, there are other infinite series whose summation never gets closer to any particular number, but continues increasing. In fact, it gets so big that the summation of all the infinite elements turns out to be positive or negative infinity. Such infinite series that do not converge at any particular number are divergent, and the property is known as divergence.

Management,Skills,Leadership,As,A,Leader,Organizing,Diverse,Ropes,Into

A single path diverging into multiple paths. (Photo Credit : Master Hands/Shutterstock)

So what is the answer to the series of integers?

As we have seen, integers follow a certain rule and therefore form a sequence. Since we want to find the summation of all the integers (both positive and negative), this means we want to find the answer to the series of the integer sequence.

But this is where the problem gets tricky. Remember those partial sums that we used to calculate the entire sum? Well, the order and form of those partial sums affect the answer of an infinite series in some cases; sadly, the summation of all integers (pos. and neg.) is one such case.

There are many ways in which the partial sums can be grouped, but for the sake of simplicity, I will provide you with two of them to make the point clear. The first, and easiest, way would be:

This gives the answer as zero, being a convergent series.

However, when we group them as:

the series becomes divergent and there is no answer for it.

Conclusion

The answer to the question is both yes and no, depending on the way the partial sums of the series of integers are calculated and grouped.

There are also more mathematically rigorous ways to deal with this problem, but they all result in the same conclusion.

Suggested Reading

Was this article helpful?
YesNo
Help us make this article better
Scientific discovery can be unexpected and full of chance surprises. Take your own here and learn something new and perhaps surprising!

Follow ScienceABC on Social Media:

About the Author

Pinak has a MSc degree in Astronomy and Astrophysics from St. Xavier’s College, Mumbai. He loves to look at stars, and can’t stop talking about them. He is currently working on his research in black hole binaries and hopes to fall into one eventually. He’s an avid reader of books and tries to write stories once in a while. And if you ever come across some weird sentences then it’s most probably his cat who wrote them.

.
Science ABC YouTube Videos

  1. Neutron Stars Explained in Simple Words for LaymenNeutron Stars Explained in Simple Words for Laymen
  2. How Robert J. Oppenheimer became the ‘Father of the Atomic Bomb’How Robert J. Oppenheimer became the ‘Father of the Atomic Bomb’
  3. Higgs Boson (The God Particle) and Higgs Field Explained in Simple WordsHiggs Boson (The God Particle) and Higgs Field Explained in Simple Words
  4. Slowing or Reversing Aging: Can We Live for 180 years?Slowing or Reversing Aging: Can We Live for 180 years?
  5. Detectives Use this Simple Technique to Find Your Fingerprints (Even AFTER You Have Wiped Them Off)!Detectives Use this Simple Technique to Find Your Fingerprints (Even AFTER You Have Wiped Them Off)!
  6. Why is a Circle 360 Degrees, Why Not a Simpler Number, like 100?Why is a Circle 360 Degrees, Why Not a Simpler Number, like 100?
  7. Quantum Mechanics Explained in Ridiculously Simple WordsQuantum Mechanics Explained in Ridiculously Simple Words
  8. Do Fish Get Thirsty and Do They Need to Drink Water?Do Fish Get Thirsty and Do They Need to Drink Water?