Would It Be Better To Have More Than Five Fingers? Would It Be Advantageous?

1 in roughly 500-1,000 children have more than five fingers on each hand. This condition, called polydactyly, has been at the center of several superstitions.

One of the ancient myths in South America concerns the Ugha Mongulala tribe of the Amazon jungle, often considered as people “chosen by the Gods”. It was said that gods with 6 fingers used to visit them, linking the scenario of having 6 fingers to divinity.

While for most of us today, polydactyly is nothing but a rare trait, recent research has shown that a completely developed and functional sixth finger can provide several advantages to individuals.

Photo,Of,Polydactyly,On,Human;,Rare,Abnormal,Characteristic,Causes,By

Comparison of a hand with 5 fingers to one with 6 fingers. The hand with 6 fingers has 2 thumbs. (Photo Credit : Thiti Sukapan/Shutterstock)

What is Polydactyly?

In medical terms, the phenomenon of having 6 fingers is known as polydactyly and was coined in 1670 by Theodore Kerckring. “Poly” means many and “dactylos” means digits or fingers, and the extra finger is referred to as a “supernumerary digit”.

There are three main types of polydactyly.

If an individual has two thumbs, they are said to have “radial polydactyly“, as “radius” is the name of the bone that supports the thumb side of our hand. It is also called “preaxial polydactyly”, as the extra finger is nearer to the first finger (thumb).

If an individual has two little fingers, they are said to have “ulnar polydactyly“, as “ulna” is the name of the bone that supports the little finger side of the hand. This condition is also called “postaxial polydactyly”, as the extra finger is nearer to the last finger (little finger).

If a person’s extra finger is a copy of any of the three other fingers, they are said to have “central polydactyly“.

Illustration of three types of Polydactyly, such as Preaxial, Central and Postaxial

Polydactyly is characterized by the presence of 6 fingers on the hands. The diagram above depicts the different types of polydactyly, preaxial (radial), central, and postaxial (ulnar). (Photo Credit : Scio21/Shutterstock)

Extra digits can occur sporadically in nature, and may be caused by environmental factors such as nutrient intake level,  exposure to hazardous chemicals before pregnancy, and a history of epilepsy.

Hereditary genetics is also a cause of polydactyly. A group of genes called the homeobox or Hox genes determines the body plan of the embryo, namely where the head and tail should grow. They ensure that structures grow in their intended locations in the body.

Research has found that certain hox genes are a cause of genetic polydactyly.

HOXA13 and HOXD13, in particular, are important for digit formation. These proteins have polyalanine tails in their structure. Mutations like addition or deletion in the polyalanine tails of these proteins result in malformations in digit formation, one of which is polydactyly.

Early tetrapods had more than 5 fingers on their hands. The evolution of these genes may be responsible for the transition from polydactyl ancestors to 5-fingered (pentadactyl) humans and 4-fingered (tetradactyl) animals.

Mutations in several other genes, such as SHH (Sonic Hedgehog) genes, IHH (Indian Hedgehog) genes, and the LMBR1 (limb development membrane protein) gene, which play a role in body development and cell communication, also affect the number of fingers we may have.

Can having 6 fingers make you more dexterous?

In 2019, researchers from the University of Freiburg published a paper in which they analyzed two subjects with an additional finger between the thumb and index finger on both hands. The study emphasized which abilities the additional finger can confer to the subjects when performing several tasks.

The study garnered some interesting observations. First, the extra finger was able to move independently of the other fingers, as it had its own bones, ligaments and tendons. This is very rare, as the extra finger is usually undeveloped or underdeveloped. Second, it was able to coordinate its actions with the other fingers, meaning that the extra finger could move as the other five fingers moved and coordinate with them to facilitate complex movements.

In most cases of polydactyly, the extra finger is just a lump of tissue without bones, ligaments or tendons, making it unable to move independently. The extra finger can only be functional when it is fully developed, with bones, tendons and ligaments.

If the extra finger lies between the thumb and index finger, it can contribute to improved coordination with the other 5 fingers.

Such subjects had versatile manipulation skills. The extra finger enabled them to complete certain tasks with just one hand that would otherwise require both hands, such as tying their shoelaces, managing mobile phone operations, playing complex video games, and efficient typing.

However, previous research has shown that this only applies to individuals with a fully developed extra finger between the thumb and index finger.

X-ray of feet in polydactyly

An X-ray image of feet with 6 fingers. In the first image, a fused bone indicates an underdeveloped extra finger, which may not provide dexterity advantages. The second image shows a foot with six fingers, where the sixth finger has independent bones, a complete structure and may therefore confer additional advantages. (Photo Credit : Mikael Häggström/Wikimedia commons)

Polydactyly is not limited to humans. Aye-Aye lemurs, a small primate, has an extra thumb (pseudo thumb) with bone and cartilage, which it uses when trying to acquire food. Furthermore, their pseudo-thumb, like human thumbs, can move in three different directions. Giant Pandas also seem to have a pseudo-thumb that helps them get a better grip on bamboo while eating.

The brain and extra fingers

Our brain controls all the movements and processes regulating our body. Does that mean the extra finger will exert pressure on the brain for its smooth functioning?

The answer is a definite “no”. The brain is more than equipped to handle the activities of an extra finger without compromising its other activities. Not only that, but the brain of individuals with an extra finger has a specific dedicated region that controls the activity of the extra finger.

A Final Word

Our four-limbed ancestors, the tetrapods, had a varied number of fingers and toes, ranging from 5 to 13 on each limb. At the end of the Devonian period, when animals had moved from water to land, almost all creatures had only five digits, though some did have four.

We don’t know the exact reason why we have only 5 fingers instead of six. This could be because, as animals evolve, it is easier to lose a trait than to gain one. That could be the reason why having six fingers is still rare.

Related Articles
Related Articles

There is no solid evidence that the extra finger can be beneficial, except from the study mentioned above. Further research, perhaps with a greater number of participants, may provide better insights into the role of an extra finger in enhanced motor abilities.

For the time being, the limited evidence available suggests that having an extra finger may provide extra skills, provided the finger is fully developed.

Help us make this article better
About the Author

Bhagya has a Doctoral degree in Biotechnology from Nirma University, Ahmedabad. She is a detail-oriented hard-working scientist with hands-on experience in several disciplines of biology. She has several research papers and review articles to her credit. She is a fervent lover of biology and wishes to make it simple for others to like and enjoy it too.

.
Science ABC YouTube Videos

  1. What Are The Different Atomic Models? Dalton, Rutherford, Bohr and Heisenberg Models ExplainedWhat Are The Different Atomic Models? Dalton, Rutherford, Bohr and Heisenberg Models Explained
  2. Why Is Blood Drawn From Veins And Not From Arteries?Why Is Blood Drawn From Veins And Not From Arteries?
  3. Emotions and the Brain: What is the limbic system?Emotions and the Brain: What is the limbic system?
  4. Dark Matter Explained: What Exactly is Dark Matter? | A Beginner’s Guide to Dark MatterDark Matter Explained: What Exactly is Dark Matter? | A Beginner’s Guide to Dark Matter
  5. What Exactly is a Tesseract? (Hint: Not a Superhero Stone)What Exactly is a Tesseract? (Hint: Not a Superhero Stone)
  6. Respiratory System: From Inspiration to Expiration Explained in Simple WordsRespiratory System: From Inspiration to Expiration Explained in Simple Words
  7. What is the Fibonacci Sequence & the Golden Ratio? Simple Explanation and Examples in Everyday LifeWhat is the Fibonacci Sequence & the Golden Ratio? Simple Explanation and Examples in Everyday Life
  8. Digestive System: Ingestion to Egestion Explained in Simple WordsDigestive System: Ingestion to Egestion Explained in Simple Words

Tags: