Why Does Your Favorite Movie Not Seem As Great When Shown To Someone Else?

Being noticed and appreciated by others (especially those people close to us) is one of the strongest motivators for human beings. For example, when we show a friend a movie that we find absolutely awesome, we expose a part of our personality and become vulnerable to judgement by them.

As a result, we tend to focus a lot on getting the right/desired feedback from our friend. Consequently, we invariably find certain flaws in the movie that might bother us and make us doubt how good it truly is!

, Why Does Your Favorite Movie Not Seem As Great When Shown To Someone Else?, Science ABC, Science ABC

“Have you watched that TV show? It’s my favorite.”

Not long ago, a friend of mine asked me if I had watched a particular TV show. I told him that I hadn’t, to which he replied that the show was his favorite, and that such an amazing show shouldn’t be missed by anyone, particularly one of his friends.

As it happened, the day when I finally watched the first episode of that show with a few other friends, he was there too. The show had been on for barely a few minutes when he started nitpicking and making comments like, “Yeah, there’s a small problem in that scene”, “This one scene is just stupid… ignore it”, “Hold on, here comes a hilarious scene” and so on.

, Why Does Your Favorite Movie Not Seem As Great When Shown To Someone Else?, Science ABC, Science ABC

We were so annoyed by his comments that we eventually had to ask him to shut up and let us decide for ourselves which characters were boring/hilarious and whether we liked the show or not.

Although I ended up enjoying the show, I also identified an important aspect of human behavior. Whenever we strongly recommend something, be it a movie, TV show, song, short video, recipe etc. to someone and endorse it as “our favorite”, we have an uncontrollable urge to find out whether they like it or not.

Moreover, we actively try to get them to like that movie, show, song etc. To that end, we sometimes even sit with our friends while they’re watching the movie, and more often than not, we end up finding flaws and little mistakes in the movie, leading us to feel that it’s not that great after all!

watching arrow tv show

Your personal favorite may not seem as awesome when you show it to your friends.

Why does that happen? Why does a great (and even our “favorite”) movie not seem as great when we show it to a friend?

Note: This is a purely subjective scenario, i.e., not everyone experiences this situation the same way that I, or someone else does. Even if they do, their reactions might differ significantly. Therefore, there’s no objective, universal answer to this question that applies to every situation. However, there are a few hypotheses that may explain some situations.

Belongingness – A very important psychological need

The feeling of belonging is a powerful and inexorable emotion that affects human nature. It’s the emotional requirement of an individual to be an accepted member of a community or group that they think is larger or greater than themselves. It leads to the formation of a relationship that is stronger than mere familiarity or acquaintance.

People laughing in group

The desire to be accepted in a group plays a significant role in driving people’s behavior.(Photo Credit : Flickr)

Many psychologists argue that the need to belong is one of the most fundamental psychological motivations that a person can have. If someone doesn’t possess a feeling of belongingness, they may have problems relating with their surroundings and communicating with others around them, which may be detrimental to them and others.

, Why Does Your Favorite Movie Not Seem As Great When Shown To Someone Else?, Science ABC, Science ABC

Maslow’s hierarchy of needs

An American psychologist named Abraham Maslow proposed a theory in 1943 claiming that a person’s psychological well-being is based on the fulfillment of a series of needs. This theory came to be popularly known as Maslow’s hierarchy of needs.

These needs are commonly presented in the shape of a pyramid, wherein the bottom level is occupied by the most basic survival needs, i.e., physiological needs such as food, water and metabolic requirements, while the top layer consists of needs relating to self-transcendence and self-actualization.

Maslows Hierarchy Of Needs

Maslow’s hierarchy of needs. (Photo Credit : FireflySixtySeven / Wikipedia Commons)

As you can see in the pyramid above, the need to belong sits on the third level. Maslow suggested that the need to belong was a major source of motivation for humans. However, some psychologists believe that the feeling of belongingness is a fundamental psychological motivator and that much of what we do is done in order to feel like we are a part of a larger group (Source).

What happens when we recommend our favorite movie, song or TV show to a friend?

When we recommend something (e.g., a movie) to a friend or colleague, we internally desire for them like it, and subsequently, for them to think of us as being cool and cultured. We want them to like us more for introducing them to such a great movie, as we want to be recognized for having such great taste.

Many psychologists claim that the need to be seen, recognized and considered valuable drives people’s behavior to a great extent. Sharing your favorite movie with someone else is a subtle act of opening up; it makes you vulnerable to someone else’s judgment. Furthermore, this is not just any random person, but someone you are actually close to, such as a friend or colleague.

, Why Does Your Favorite Movie Not Seem As Great When Shown To Someone Else?, Science ABC, Science ABC

Since you make yourself vulnerable by sharing your favorite movie with a friend, you become overly focused on getting the desired feedback from them, which is why you start doubting the movie’s quality and questioning whether it actually is that great.

However, the desire to be appreciated by someone you care about may not be the only reason behind such a reaction. Sometimes, when you watch a show, it usually takes some time before you start noticing and enjoying the small idiosyncrasies of the cast.

, Why Does Your Favorite Movie Not Seem As Great When Shown To Someone Else?, Science ABC, Science ABC

For instance, Joey’s (a character from Friends, a popular American sitcom) signature ‘How you doin’?’ might not seem as hilarious to a person who is watching the show for the first time. However, for someone who has been watching it for years, it may be one of the funniest elements of the entire show.

So, when someone starts watching the first episode of a comedy show, where they don’t know anything about the plot or characters, they may not share your enthusiasm for it. That doesn’t necessarily mean they don’t like it; it simply means they haven’t watched it as much as you to find those little details funny or amusing.

There may be other reasons too. When you show a TV show to a friend, it’s highly likely that you have watched it at least once. However, when you watch it for the second, fourth or tenth time, you start to notice small errors and flaws that you missed before, and you may begin thinking that the show is not that perfect after all.

It’s important to remember that no one really likes it when you share something with them in the hopes of getting a particular kind of reaction that pleases you, as this puts the person on the spot. Now, there is pressure involved, so they have to like that song because you hyped it so much by labeling it as your “favorite”.

, Why Does Your Favorite Movie Not Seem As Great When Shown To Someone Else?, Science ABC, Science ABC

In a nutshell, it’s completely normal to feel that your favorite show/movie/song is not as great when you show it your friends. In fact, many people feel that exact same way. Just remember to not over-hype things before showing them to others, and accept that even if your choices and preferences match in general, they may end up hating your “favorite” thing.

And that’s completely okay!


  1. Wayne State University
  2. Harvard University
  3. Psychology – University of Kentucky
  4. Thorkildsen – University of Illinois at Chicago
  5. Academia.edu
The short URL of the present article is: http://sciabc.us/uylYq
Help us make this article better
About the Author

Ashish is a Science graduate (Bachelor of Science) from Punjabi University (India). He spends a lot of time watching movies, and an awful lot more time discussing them. He likes Harry Potter and the Avengers, and obsesses over how thoroughly Science dictates every aspect of life… in this universe, at least.

Science ABC YouTube Videos

  1. Can Mutations Make Us Superheros?Can Mutations Make Us Superheros?
  2. Gravitational Lensing: What It Is And How It Is Helping Us Discover New GalaxiesGravitational Lensing: What It Is And How It Is Helping Us Discover New Galaxies
  3. What Exactly is Archimedes Principle: Explained in Simple WordsWhat Exactly is Archimedes Principle: Explained in Simple Words
  4. What is Evolution? A Simple and Brief ExplanationWhat is Evolution? A Simple and Brief Explanation
  5. What is the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle: Explained in Simple WordsWhat is the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle: Explained in Simple Words
  6. Why Are Planetary Orbits Elliptical?Why Are Planetary Orbits Elliptical?
  7. Why Are There Stones Along Railway Tracks?Why Are There Stones Along Railway Tracks?
  8. Why Do We Dance To Music?Why Do We Dance To Music?