Would the RMS Titanic Have Survived If It Had Collided Head-On With The Iceberg?

No. The idea that the ship should have maintained its course and rammed into the iceberg head-on to minimize damages is far from plausible and is also scientifically inaccurate.

On the fateful day of 14 April 1912, the RMS Titanic, a luxury passenger ship described as “unsinkable,” collided with an iceberg, causing an accident of catastrophic proportions. Hundreds of lives were lost, accompanied by a massive loss of property.

After the accident, experts from all over the world examined the entire episode with surgical precision. Several hypotheses were put forward as to what could have been done to minimize the losses caused by the collision, one of which stated that if the Titanic had collided head-on with the iceberg, the damage to life and property would have been much less serious.


Recommended Video for you:


What if the Titanic hit the iceberg head-on?

In the aftermath of the accident, some people argued that if the ship had not tried to maneuver a turn at the last moment but had instead continued on its original course, fewer lives would have been lost.

As the ship had collision bulkheads in the bow, it would most likely have survived the damage. Moreover, the impact would have flooded the first three or at most four watertight compartments. As the Titanic was designed to remain underwater with four watertight compartments, such a catastrophic loss of life could have been avoided.

titanic and iceberg

Credit: Michael Rosskothen/Shutterstock

Those who agreed with this hypothesis blamed First Officer Murdoch for his irresponsible actions that led to the disaster.

Why did the Titanic hit the iceberg sideways instead of head-on?

titanic sinking

How did the ship sink?

The Titanic, a 55,000-tonne ship, was traveling at 22 knots, almost 41 km / h. They were trying to steer the ship to the left to avoid a direct collision, but the collision occurred, and the iceberg scraped along the side of the ship and tore its hull apart.

Here is a video showing how the collision actually happened:

3 Problems With a Head-on Collision

Bulkheads: Not as effective against an iceberg

The collision bulkheads on the bow of the Titanic were designed to survive a collision with another ship, but not an iceberg! They were erected as a precaution against such an event as happened to the RMS Republic in 1909.

bulkhead

A bulkhead is an upright wall within the hull of a ship to divide compartments to avoid flooding.

The compartments of such bulkheads were more or less like the ‘crumple zones’ of modern vehicles, meaning that they absorbed most of the energy of the impact following a collision. The same thing would happen with the other ship (that collided with yours), as it also absorbed some of the energy of the impact. In such a case, both the vessels would sustain heavy damages but would likely still stay afloat.

If the Titanic were to collide with the iceberg – a stationary, mammoth object – most of the energy of the impact would have to be absorbed by the ship, which would have only made matters worse.

Abrupt Halt: Utterly Undesirable!

If the Titanic had rammed head-on into the iceberg, it would have come to a halt almost immediately; just think of what it feels like when you see a car swerving in front of you, and you suddenly step on the brakes.

An abrupt stop would have thrown people against cabins or berths, and since it was night and most passengers were asleep, they would have had absolutely no chance of bracing against the impact; they would have been flung into the things in their immediate vicinity. In addition, the condition of the workers at the front of the ship would have been even worse.

Extensive damage

In the event of a frontal collision, the impact would have extended the entire length of the ship, splitting seams and bursting rivets, in which case many more of the ship’s compartments would have been exposed to the sea, causing the ship to sink much faster.

The idea that the ship would have survived if it had crashed head-on into the iceberg is therefore crazy; there are several claims and hypotheses that suggest a variety of approaches that could have reduced, if not completely avoided, the severity of the tragic wreck of the RMS Titanic. Still, it is definitely not one of them.

Do you know what would have happened had Titanic collided head-on with the iceberg?

Answer a few questions based and assess your understanding.

Suggested Reading

Was this article helpful?
YesNo
Help us make this article better

Follow ScienceABC on Social Media:

About the Author

Ashish is a Science graduate (Bachelor of Science) from Punjabi University (India). He spearheads the content and editorial wing of ScienceABC and manages its official Youtube channel. He’s a Harry Potter fan and tries, in vain, to use spells and charms (Accio! [insert object name]) in real life to get things done. He totally gets why JRR Tolkien would create, from scratch, a language spoken by elves, and tries to bring the same passion in everything he does. A big admirer of Richard Feynman and Nikola Tesla, he obsesses over how thoroughly science dictates every aspect of life… in this universe, at least.

.
Science ABC YouTube Videos

  1. Do Fish Get Thirsty and Do They Need to Drink Water?Do Fish Get Thirsty and Do They Need to Drink Water?
  2. Gasoline (Petrol) vs Diesel: Which one is better? A Beginner’s GuideGasoline (Petrol) vs Diesel: Which one is better? A Beginner’s Guide
  3. Black Holes Explained: What Is a Black Hole? How They Form?Black Holes Explained: What Is a Black Hole? How They Form?
  4. Gut Microbiome Explained in Simple WordsGut Microbiome Explained in Simple Words
  5. Particle accelerators: What are they, how do they work and why are they important to us?Particle accelerators: What are they, how do they work and why are they important to us?
  6. How Do Neurons Work?How Do Neurons Work?
  7. How Scientifically Accurate Is The HBO Miniseries Chernobyl?How Scientifically Accurate Is The HBO Miniseries Chernobyl?
  8. Cellular Respiration: How Do Cell Get Energy?Cellular Respiration: How Do Cell Get Energy?